Call Us: 414-963-9303 - Email:
Protecting Creditors' Rights Since 1980

Bill Rinehart, Jr.

Bill Rinehart, Jr.


Main:(414) 963-9303
Cell:(414) 550-1880

Focus Areas

  • Debt Collection
  • Commercial Debt Collection
  • Retail Debt Collection
  • Consumer Debt Collection
  • Commercial Contract Litigation


  • University of Wisconsin Law School, cum laude, 2005
  • University of Minnesota, Carlson School of Management, Business, 2000

Bill Rinehart, Jr. practices in the areas of construction litigation, commercial collection, contract litigation, debt collection, creditors’ rights, commercial and retail/consumer collection, and commercial litigation. Bill Jr.’s clients range from small, locally owned businesses to Fortune 500 companies, and include banks, manufacturers, suppliers, distributors, dealers, hospitals, assisted living facilities, and health care providers. Prior to joining Rinehart, Scaffidi & Mathews, now Rinehart, Scaffidi & Rinehart, LLC, as a partner, Bill Jr. worked in the area of commercial litigation at Reinhart Boerner Van Deuren s.c., where he represented a range of business clients involved in warranty, contract, and supply chain disputes. Bill Jr.’s large firm litigation background fits nicely with RSM’s approach to helping clients hold others to their promises and allows Bill Jr. to handle contested or disputed collection matters efficiently.

Collection and Contract Litigation Experience

  • Collecting over $500,000 judgment on behalf of commercial client.
  • Collecting $250,000 business judgment.
  • Winning over $50,000 judgment after trial for a demolition construction subcontractor who was not paid the contract balance and faced counterclaims in excess of $100,000.
  • Securing settlement for 85% of construction concrete subcontractor’s claim after moving for summary judgment  on a claim for account stated. The prime contractor sought an extension to file its reply brief and thereafter the matter was settled.
  • Securing $50,000 settlement for a subcontractor—80% of the principal balance claimed due—the week before a hearing on the subcontractor’s motion for summary judgment on claims for breach of contract and theft by contractor.
  • Collecting $250,000 for business client in single matter involving U.S. and Canadian debtor entities and claims of breach of contract and personal guarantees.
  • Collecting over $60,000 in single matter for commercial lending client with a secured interest in accounts receivable.
  • Collecting over $50,000 in single matter for commercial lending client with a secured interest in accounts receivable.
  • Securing  settlement of over $40,000 for client after locating debtor’s second home through asset search and initiating liquidation process.
  • Collecting judgment in full on behalf of a furniture supplier owed money by a Wisconsin debtor. Bill Rinehart, Jr. regularly represents businesses including furniture suppliers involved in contract disputes and debt collection matters.
  • Securing judgment in full at a contested hearing despite debtor’s claims of fraud and misrepresentation.
  • Settling and litigating dozens of collection claims involving receivables outstanding for 90 or more days and which involved counterclaims or the threat of counterclaims.
  • Representing banks and other lenders in matters involving loan defaults, accounts receivable, and replevins.
  • Collected over $100,000 on behalf of condominium association for past due maintenance fees.


  • Wisconsin Super Lawyers, Rising Stars, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017 (awarded to lawyers under 40 or with less than 10 years of practice; awarded to 2.5% of lawyers in WI)
  • Co-presenter on  Health Care Collections, Leading Age Wisconsin, 2014 Spring Conference, Wisconsin Dells, Wisconsin
  • Presenter, Leading Age Wisconsin, Serve It Up, 2013, Green Bay, WI
  • Co-developed presentation and related speech directed to long term care contract and accounts receibable issues, Service For Nothing:  How to Manage the Collection of Past-Due Accounts to Protect your Organization
  • Member, International Association of Commercial Collectors (IACC)
  • Attorney Member, Commercial Collection Agencies of America
  • Wisconsin Law Review (Managing Editor, Senior Administrative Editor, Malt & Barley Editor)
  • Milwaukee Bar Association; Seventh Circuit Bar Association
  • University of Wisconsin Law School Alumni Association
  • Volunteer Lawyer, VLP-Domestic Abuse Injunction Project, 2007-2011
  • High School Mock Trial Coach/Volunteer, 2009-2011
  • Wisconsin Supreme Court Intern (Justice Patrick Crooks, 2004-05)
  • Admitted to practice in Wisconsin state courts, United States District Court for the Eastern District of Wisconsin, United District Court for the Western District of Wisconsin, United States District Court for the Northern District of Illinois, United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, and United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit
Back to Top